Contents8 sections
Who is involved in a card paymentLink to this section
Before comparing models, it helps to separate the roles:
- Cardholder and issuer. The customer pays with a card issued by their bank, the issuer.
- Card scheme. Visa, Mastercard and others set the rules and run the networks that connect issuers and acquirers.
- Acquirer. The scheme member that signs the merchant, submits its transactions into the network and settles the funds. Visa defines an acquirer as a member that signs a merchant or payment facilitator and directly or indirectly enters transactions into interchange.
- Processor. The technical platform that handles authorisation, clearing and settlement messages on the acquirer’s behalf. It may belong to the acquirer or be a third party.
- Gateway. The software that connects your checkout to a processor or acquirer: it collects card data securely, requests authorisation and returns the result.
Card acquiring is a regulated activity. In the UK, “issuing payment instruments or acquiring payment transactions” is one of the payment services listed in the Payment Services Regulations 2017 (Schedule 1, Part 1), so an acquirer must be a bank, an authorised payment institution or an electronic money institution. Whatever model you choose, there is always a licensed, scheme-member acquirer somewhere in the chain. The question is how close you sit to it.
Model 1: a direct acquiring relationshipLink to this section
You sign a merchant agreement with the acquirer, which underwrites your business and issues you your own merchant identification number (MID). You connect through a gateway — your own, the acquirer’s or a third party’s — and the acquirer settles funds to your bank account.
Contracting and onboarding. Expect full underwriting: company documents, details of directors and beneficial owners, financial information, processing history if you have it, and a website review. It is the slowest of the three routes to set up; how long it takes depends mostly on your category and how complete your application is.
Risk. The acquirer takes your risk onto its own books and manages it directly through your contract: reserves, settlement timing, volume limits and monitoring. Because the relationship is individual, these terms can be negotiated and revisited as your history improves.
Pricing. Direct relationships are often priced as interchange plus plus (IC++): the interchange fee paid to the issuer, plus the scheme fees charged by Visa or Mastercard, plus the acquirer’s own margin, each shown separately. In the UK, interchange on consumer debit cards is capped at 0.2% of the transaction value for UK transactions, and on consumer credit cards at 0.3% (the Interchange Fee Regulation as retained in UK law). IC++ is transparent but variable: your cost moves with your card mix.
Control. You have your own MID, a direct line to your acquirer’s risk team, more say over your billing descriptor, and data that belongs to your account. Many larger merchants hold more than one direct relationship for resilience and routing.
Best for established businesses with meaningful volume, businesses in categories that most aggregated models exclude, and anyone who needs negotiated terms or several acquirers.
Model 2: a payment service providerLink to this section
“Payment service provider” is used loosely in the industry. On a website it usually means a company that sells you a complete package — gateway, acquiring, fraud tools, reporting and sometimes alternative payment methods — under one contract. Behind that package, the PSP may:
- be a licensed acquirer itself, issuing you your own MID on its own licence; or
- resell another institution’s acquiring, either arranging a MID for you at a partner acquirer or bringing you on as a sub-merchant under its own account — in which case it is operating as a payment facilitator.
You will also meet independent sales organisations (ISOs) and agents: businesses that market and sometimes service an acquirer’s merchant accounts without being the acquirer. Visa’s rules call these and similar providers third party agents; the acquirer remains responsible for them.
Contracting and onboarding. One contract, one integration and one dashboard, with onboarding that sits between a PayFac and a direct acquirer in speed and depth.
Pricing. Often blended — a single percentage plus a fixed fee per transaction — sometimes with IC++ available at higher volumes.
Best for businesses that want one supplier for the whole payment stack and a straightforward integration, with room to grow into better terms.
The key point is to find out which entity is your acquirer and whose MID you are on. It changes who decides on your account, how portable your setup is and what happens if the relationship ends.
Model 3: a payment facilitatorLink to this section
A payment facilitator contracts with an acquirer to sign up merchants of its own — called sponsored merchants or sub-merchants — and to submit their transactions and receive settlement on their behalf. That is how Visa defines a payment facilitator in its rules.
Contracting and onboarding. You accept the PayFac’s standard terms, often online. The PayFac carries out the checks on behalf of its acquirer, so a low-risk business can usually start taking payments far sooner than through a direct relationship. Visa requires the acquirer to register each PayFac, confirm its due diligence, and ensure every transaction carries both the PayFac’s identifier and the sponsored merchant’s identifier (Visa Core Rules, section 5.3.1.3). Mastercard lets the acquirer delegate checks, settlement and monitoring to the PayFac but keeps the acquirer fully responsible if the PayFac fails to perform them (Mastercard Rules, rule 7.6.5.1).
Risk. Liability flows upwards. The PayFac is financially liable for each transaction of its sponsored merchants, and the acquirer is liable for everything the PayFac and its merchants do (Visa Core Rules, sections 5.3.1.1 and 5.3.1.2). Because the PayFac underwrites quickly and at scale, it protects itself with standard, automated controls. That is why PayFac accounts are more likely to see sudden holds, reserves or closures when activity changes — a spike in volume, a run of disputes, a new product line — and why there is usually less room to negotiate.
Pricing. Typically blended and simple. You pay for speed and convenience; at higher volumes this often costs more than a direct relationship.
Descriptor. For PayFac transactions, Visa requires the receipt to show the name of the payment facilitator and the name of the sponsored merchant (or an abbreviation) (section 5.9.2.2). Your customers’ statements identify both, usually as the PayFac’s name followed by yours.
The USD 1 million rule. Visa requires an acquirer to sign a direct merchant agreement with a sponsored merchant whose annual transaction volume exceeds USD 1 million — before processing for a new sponsored merchant, or within two years for an existing one. The PayFac may still provide services, including settlement. There are exceptions, for example where the PayFac has held the relationship with the same acquirer for at least two years and reports regularly on the merchant’s volume, disputes and fraud, or where the merchant is in certain categories such as utilities, education, healthcare or government payments (Visa Core Rules, section 5.3.1.4). In practice this means a growing PayFac merchant will eventually have a direct contractual link with an acquirer whether or not it changes provider.
Who can be a PayFac merchant. PayFacs choose their own risk appetite within limits set by their acquirer. Many exclude high-risk and registered categories altogether. A PayFac that does serve them must register with Visa as a high-integrity risk payment facilitator (section 5.3.1.3). A sponsored merchant whose contract was terminated at the direction of Visa or a government agency cannot be signed (section 5.3.1.1), and Mastercard acquirers and approved PayFacs check the MATCH Pro list of terminated merchants before onboarding.
Best for new and small businesses, low-risk categories, platforms that want to embed payments quickly, and anyone who values speed over customisation.
MarketplacesLink to this section
A marketplace is related but distinct: Visa defines it as an entity that brings together cardholders and retailers on a website or app, and processes transactions and receives settlement on behalf of those retailers. Visa requires the receipt to name both the marketplace and the retailer, and the marketplace must show the retailer’s country during checkout. Platforms deciding whether to become a PayFac, operate as a marketplace or use a provider’s embedded model should take legal advice, because receiving and holding funds for others is generally a regulated payment service in the UK and EU.
Side-by-sideLink to this section
| Direct acquirer | PSP (own MID) | Payment facilitator | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Your contract is with | The acquirer | The PSP | The PayFac |
| Merchant ID | Your own | Usually your own | The PayFac’s, with a sub-merchant ID |
| Onboarding speed | Slowest | In between | Fastest |
| Underwriting | Full, individual | Full or standardised | Standardised, automated |
| Pricing | Often IC++ | Blended or IC++ | Usually blended |
| Negotiable terms | Yes | Partly | Rarely |
| Risk tolerance | Widest range, incl. registered categories with specialist acquirers | Depends on provider | Usually low-risk only |
| Account holds | Contractual, negotiated | Contractual | Automated, can be sudden |
| Descriptor | Your name | Your name | PayFac name plus yours |
Choosing a modelLink to this section
Consider these questions in order:
- What is your risk profile? If you are in a category that schemes require to be registered, or one most providers treat as high risk, your realistic options are acquirers and PSPs with appetite for it. See what “high risk” really means.
- How quickly do you need to trade? A PayFac gets a low-risk business live fastest. A direct relationship needs preparation, which you can do in parallel.
- How much will you process? At low volumes, simplicity outweighs price. As volume grows, the difference between blended and IC++ pricing becomes material, and the USD 1 million threshold starts to matter.
- How much control do you need? Your own MID, negotiated reserves, a recognisable descriptor and the ability to run more than one acquirer all point towards direct or own-MID relationships.
- Can you move? Ask before signing whether you can export stored card data to another PCI DSS-compliant provider if you leave. For subscription businesses, being unable to migrate stored cards can tie you to a provider.
Questions to ask any providerLink to this section
- Who is the acquirer, and in which country is it licensed?
- Will I have my own MID, or be a sub-merchant?
- What is your regulatory status? (In the UK, check the Financial Services Register.)
- What reserve, settlement delay and volume limits apply, and when are they reviewed?
- In what circumstances can you hold funds or close my account, and with how much notice?
- How will my business appear on customers’ statements?
- What are the chargeback fees, and which pre-dispute tools are available?
- Can I export my customers’ stored cards if I leave?
One rule applies to every model in the UK: you may not add a surcharge for paying with a consumer debit or credit card (Consumer Rights (Payment Surcharges) Regulations 2012, regulation 6A), so your processing cost has to be built into your prices.
What to do nextLink to this section
Choosing between these models is easier with a clear view of how each provider will see your business. The ValyrPay Merchant Services is a consulting and referral service: we assess your profile, explain which models and providers are realistic for it, and introduce you to acquirers and payment service providers whose appetite fits. We do not hold funds or make approval decisions — the acquirer underwrites and decides — and we may receive referral fees from the providers we introduce. Start with merchant accounts.
Sources
Each source was read on the date shown. Card-scheme rules and regulations change; check the current edition before relying on a detail.
- Visa Core Rules and Visa Product and Service Rules, edition 18 April 2026 (sections 1.4.3.3, 5.3.1.1–5.3.1.4, 5.9.2.2; glossary) (external site)
- Visa Payment Facilitator and Marketplace Risk Guide (April 2021) (external site)
- Mastercard Rules, 2 June 2026 (rules 7.6.5 and 7.6.5.1) (external site)
- Mastercard Security Rules and Procedures — Merchant Edition, 4 August 2026 (chapter 11, MATCH Pro) (external site)
- The Payment Services Regulations 2017, Schedule 1, Part 1 (external site)
- Regulation (EU) 2015/751 on interchange fees for card-based payment transactions, as retained in UK law, article 3 (debit) (external site)
- Regulation (EU) 2015/751 as retained in UK law, article 4 (credit) (external site)
- The Consumer Rights (Payment Surcharges) Regulations 2012, regulation 6A (external site)