Contents8 sections
Why subscriptions get special treatmentLink to this section
A subscription turns one decision into many payments. That creates familiar problems: forgotten renewals, trials that converted unnoticed, cancellations that did not work and charges the customer does not recognise. When those customers phone their bank instead of the merchant, the result is a chargeback. Mastercard said as much when it revised its rules in 2022: its own data showed recurring transactions were more likely to be disputed than one-off purchases. The scheme rules, and the UK’s new consumer rules, target the same failure points.
The vocabularyLink to this section
- Recurring transaction — in Visa’s definition, one of a series of charges on a stored card at fixed, regular intervals of no more than a year, under the cardholder’s agreement. Charges made without the customer present are merchant-initiated transactions.
- Trial, introductory or promotional period — a free or reduced-price period that rolls into a full-price subscription unless the customer cancels.
- Negative option — a model where the customer is charged unless they act to decline. Mastercard applies the term to free or low-cost trials that enrol the customer into recurring billing.
Visa’s rulesLink to this section
Visa’s requirements sit in the Visa Core Rules and Visa Product and Service Rules (edition of 18 April 2026), mainly in tables 5-20 to 5-22 and section 5.8.17.
At sign-upLink to this section
Before storing a card for future charges, the merchant must obtain the cardholder’s express, informed consent to an agreement covering, among other things: what is sold, the total price, cancellation and refund policies, the merchant’s location and contact details, the last four digits of the card, the amount (or how it is calculated), currency, timing and frequency of charges, how changes will be notified, any expiry date and the length of any trial or introductory offer. These terms must be displayed when the customer consents, separately from the general terms and conditions, and kept for the life of the agreement.
In Visa’s Europe region, which includes the UK, there are additional rules. The page where the card is entered and the checkout screen must both show the merchant name, a description of what is sold, the length of any trial, the amount due now (even if zero), the amount and fixed date or interval of each recurring charge, the last four digits of the card and clear cancellation and refund terms. The merchant must confirm the recurring agreement to the cardholder within 2 business days.
Before the first charge — or, where nothing is due yet, through an account verification — the merchant must obtain an approval from the card issuer. If that first request is declined, the card must not be stored.
During the subscriptionLink to this section
For recurring transactions Visa requires the merchant to:
- provide a simple cancellation procedure and, if the customer signed up online, at least an online way to cancel;
- process charges on the fixed dates or intervals agreed;
- notify the customer by email or another agreed method at least 7 days before a recurring charge if a trial, introductory or promotional period is about to end. The notice must include the amount and date of the coming charges and a link or other simple way to cancel online or by text message.
In the Europe region the same 7-day notice is also required when more than six months have passed since the previous recurring charge, or when the agreement has changed — including its amount or date.
Recurring charges must not include finance charges or interest, and the merchant must refund in full if it has not kept to the terms of the sale.
Negative option merchantsLink to this section
Negative option merchants have further steps (section 5.8.17.2 and table 5-31). The checkout screen must show, among other things, the length of any trial, a clear statement that the customer will be charged unless they cancel, the amounts and dates of the first and later charges, and an easy way to cancel. Consent must be captured with a “click to accept” button, a receipt or written confirmation must follow immediately, and emailed receipts and notices must link to a page where the subscription can easily be cancelled. The 7-day notice applies before any charge that follows a trial or a change of terms.
On the statementLink to this section
In Visa’s Europe region, the clearing record for a recurring transaction between countries in the region must carry the merchant’s website address in the merchant name field for an e-commerce merchant, or an internationally accessible telephone number in the city field for other merchants (Visa Core Rules, section 1.4.3.3). This is one of several reasons descriptors matter so much for subscriptions; see our guide to payment descriptors.
Mastercard’s rulesLink to this section
Mastercard’s requirements are in its Transaction Processing Rules, rule 5.4. Mastercard implemented the current version on 11 October 2022.
All subscription merchants (rule 5.4.1)Link to this section
- Disclose the terms at the moment you ask for card details. The disclosure must include the price and how often it will be charged — Mastercard’s example is wording such as “You will be billed USD 9.95 per month until you cancel the subscription.” Trial offers must also state any initial charge, the trial length and the price and frequency afterwards. Online, the terms must be clearly and prominently displayed on the payment and order summary pages, and the customer must affirmatively accept them. A link to another page, a box the customer has to expand, or terms the customer must scroll down to find do not satisfy the rule.
- Send a confirmation immediately after sign-up, by email or another electronic method, with the subscription terms and instructions for cancelling.
- Send a receipt after each successful charge with the amount, the reason and how to cancel. This is a recommendation, but it becomes mandatory for a merchant identified for four months or more as an Excessive Chargeback Merchant, High Excessive Chargeback Merchant or Excessive Fraud Merchant.
- Offer an online or electronic cancellation method — Mastercard compares it to unsubscribing from emails — or clear, easily found online instructions, such as a “Manage subscription” or “Cancel subscription” link on the home page.
- Remind customers before infrequent charges. Where billing happens every six months or less often (six-monthly, annually and so on), send an electronic reminder at least 7 and no more than 30 days before the next billing date, with the terms and how to cancel. The subject line must make clear that it concerns upcoming charges, and the message must be separate from marketing.
These standards do not apply to utilities, telecommunications, insurance or existing debt such as loan repayments, and they are best practice only for charities — unless the charity enters Mastercard’s chargeback monitoring categories for four months or more (rule 5.4.1.1).
Negative option merchants (rule 5.4.2)Link to this section
- Digital goods and services with a trial longer than 7 days: send a reminder no less than 3 and no more than 7 days before the trial ends, stating that the subscription will start unless the customer cancels, with the basic terms and clear cancellation instructions.
- Physical products: all later recurring charges must use the same merchant ID and merchant name as the first transaction. After the trial, and before the first full-price charge, the merchant must give the customer the start date, the amount, the payment date, the merchant name as it will appear on the statement and how to cancel — and obtain the customer’s explicit consent. A receipt with cancellation instructions must follow every approved charge. The customer must be told in writing at least 7 days before billing terms change, and within 7 days of a cancellation.
- For physical-product trials, the trial starts on the date the customer receives the product, and the website where the customer signed up must link directly to an online cancellation procedure (rule 5.1.1).
Mastercard also requires acquirers to register negative option merchants selling physical products under MCC 5968 in its Specialty Merchant Registration Program (Security Rules and Procedures, section 9.1).
The UK subscription contract regimeLink to this section
Where it stands in October 2026Link to this section
The Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act 2024 (DMCCA) received Royal Assent on 24 May 2024, and most of its consumer provisions took effect on 6 April 2025. The subscription chapter (Part 4, Chapter 2) needs regulations and guidance before it applies.
On 19 October 2026 the government laid the draft Consumer Subscription Contracts (Cancellation and Information) Regulations 2026 before Parliament and published draft guidance alongside them. The draft guidance states that the rules apply to subscription contracts entered into on or after 1 January 2027. The regulations must be approved by both Houses of Parliament before they take effect, so treat that date as expected rather than certain until they are made.
What the regime requiresLink to this section
The rules cover business-to-consumer contracts that renew automatically, including free or reduced-price periods that roll into a full or higher price, however the customer signs up. Utilities, financial services, telecoms, certain charity memberships and some other categories are excluded. The draft guidance says that traders based outside the UK who sell to UK consumers need to comply. In summary, traders must:
- Give key pre-contract information before sign-up — including that the contract renews unless the customer acts, any minimum period, what happens when a trial ends and how much the first full charge is, the payment frequency and amount (with a monthly equivalent if billing is not monthly), how to end the contract and when reminders will be sent. Online, the customer must be able to read this during the purchase journey without clicking through to another page.
- Provide full pre-contract information, which may be linked, and then confirm it on a durable medium such as email.
- Send reminder notices at set points: roughly every six months, before a free or discounted period ends, and before renewal onto a term of 12 months or longer — in which case an additional, earlier reminder is also required. Reminders must be timed to give the customer a real opportunity to cancel.
- Make leaving straightforward. Customers can end the contract at any time. If they joined online, they must be able to leave online; the draft guidance says an email address alone is not a straightforward online exit. Retention offers must not prolong or discourage exit, and feedback must be optional.
- Confirm the exit with an end-of-contract notice within 24 hours of an online cancellation, or within 3 working days otherwise.
- Not charge for a renewal before it starts.
Customers gain a 14-day cooling-off period at the start of the contract and again after a trial ends or after renewal onto a term of 12 months or more, with full or proportionate refunds depending on what has been supplied. If a trader fails to give certain key information or reminders, customers can cancel and may be entitled to refunds.
The Competition and Markets Authority can enforce these rules directly, with penalties of up to £300,000 or 10% of global turnover, whichever is higher (draft guidance, section 10.2).
What this means for chargebacksLink to this section
The disputes you will seeLink to this section
Subscription disputes tend to fall into a few groups:
- Cancelled recurring transaction — the customer says they cancelled, or withdrew permission, before the charge. Under Visa’s Dispute Condition 13.2 the issuer has 120 days from processing, and the dispute is limited to the unused portion of the service. For disputes processed on or after 18 April 2026, a 13.2 dispute is invalid where the cancellation came after the transaction date.
- Not recognised or not authorised — the customer does not recognise the descriptor or says they never agreed to recurring charges, which is often raised as fraud.
- Not as described — the trial was presented as free, the price was unclear, or the product did not match.
Mastercard handles these mainly through its cardholder dispute chargeback, which includes a specific path for disputes of a recurring transaction.
Why prevention matters more than winningLink to this section
Visa’s monitoring programme, VAMP, counts disputes as they are raised and measures them against your settled transactions; payment providers report that a dispute you later win still counts. Disputes resolved through pre-dispute tools are excluded (Visa VAMP fact sheet, 2025). Mastercard’s receipt requirement turns from recommended to mandatory if your chargebacks remain excessive for four months. In other words, the schemes reward preventing disputes, not fighting them — see chargeback alerts explained.
Evidence to keep for every subscriberLink to this section
- Dated copies of every version of your checkout and the terms shown at sign-up.
- The consent record: timestamp, method, IP address or device.
- The confirmation, every reminder and receipt, with delivery records.
- Cancellation requests, end-of-contract notices, and usage or delivery records.
A single flow that meets all three regimesLink to this section
| Step | Visa | Mastercard | UK rules (expected from 1 Jan 2027) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Show terms at sign-up | Separately from general terms; on card entry page and checkout in Europe | On payment and order summary pages; no links, expand boxes or scrolling | Key information in the purchase journey, not behind a link |
| Consent | Express, informed consent; click-to-accept for negative option | Affirmative acceptance; explicit consent before first full-price charge for physical trials | Clear information before the contract is made |
| Confirm | Within 2 business days in Europe | Immediately, with cancellation instructions | Full information on a durable medium |
| Remind | 7+ days before a trial ends; in Europe also after 6 months or on changes | 3–7 days before a digital trial ends; 7–30 days before infrequent charges | Roughly every 6 months, before trials end and before 12-month renewals |
| Cancel | Simple; online if signed up online | Online or electronic, easy to find | Straightforward; online if joined online; notice within 24 hours |
| Receipts | Required for negative option | Recommended; mandatory in monitoring | Not specified beyond notices |
Design to the strictest entry in each row: every term beside the card fields, an unticked consent box, an immediate confirmation, reminders before every trial end and long renewal, a cancellation button in the account area and every email, and a receipt after every charge.
What to do nextLink to this section
If you run subscriptions or trials, a review of your sign-up, reminder and cancellation journey is usually the quickest way to cut disputes. The ValyrPay Merchant Services can map your flow against Visa’s and Mastercard’s rules and the UK regime, fix your descriptors and set up pre-dispute tools. We are not a bank or a payment institution, and the card schemes and your acquirer decide how your disputes are handled. See chargeback prevention.
Sources
Each source was read on the date shown. Card-scheme rules and regulations change; check the current edition before relying on a detail.
- Visa Core Rules and Visa Product and Service Rules, edition 18 April 2026 (tables 5-20, 5-21, 5-22, 5-31; sections 1.4.3.3, 5.8.17.2, 11.10.3; glossary) (external site)
- Mastercard Transaction Processing Rules, 10 June 2025 (rules 5.1.1, 5.4.1, 5.4.1.1, 5.4.2) (external site)
- Mastercard Security Rules and Procedures — Merchant Edition, 4 August 2026 (section 9.1, MCC 5968 registration) (external site)
- Mastercard — Greater Transparency for Cardholders: Modified Requirements for Subscription and Negative Option Billing Models (November 2022) (external site)
- Mastercard Chargeback Guide — Merchant Edition, 19 May 2026 (cardholder dispute of a recurring transaction) (external site)
- GOV.UK — Subscription contracts (guidance publication page, 19 October 2026) (external site)
- Department for Business and Trade — Draft guidance on the subscription contracts rules (October 2026) (external site)
- Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act 2024, Part 4, Chapter 2 (external site)
- UK Parliament — The Consumer Subscription Contracts (Cancellation and Information) Regulations 2026 (draft affirmative instrument, laid 19 October 2026) (external site)
- legislation.gov.uk — Draft Consumer Subscription Contracts (Cancellation and Information) Regulations 2026 (external site)
- Visa Acquirer Monitoring Program Overview (fact sheet, 2025) (external site)